What "All-or-Nothing" says about you

Chronic dissatisfaction may say more about you than your relationship.

Chronic dissatisfaction may say more about you than your relationship.
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

For some who have experienced a less than happy track record in the dating world, the scariest time in any romantic relationship is when it starts to look like it’s actually going to work out. For the most vulnerable, criticism and doubts about their partner surface at breakneck speed and the validity of the entire relationship comes into question.

All in all, though, it seems that chronic dissatisfaction and criticism of a mate may speak more to fears of disappointment than any real incompatibilities in a relationship.

A recent study conducted at Yale University found that people who think about their partner in fluctuating terms of all good or all bad suffered from poor self-esteem. They also tended to get into relationships quickly and idealized their partners as being better than they really were in reality. Then when they perceived even the smallest of faults in their partner, they tended to withdraw into themselves in an attempt to avoid feelings of disappointment. Overly critical, all-or-nothing thinkers stifle their own needs until their lack of fulfillment explodes into criticisms and resentments. Over time they may not have any idea what they’re looking for in a partner.

 While it can be easy to be lenient about another's perceived shortcomings at the start of a relationship, as time lags hidden expectations go unfulfilled. Many people routinely choose incompatible relationships from the start, settling for less than their true needs because that new partner accepts them as they are, despite all of the awful things their sense of low self-esteem and self-worth seem to tell them. And rather than seeing people as having both positives and negatives, overly critical people hold their romantic partners to an unrealistic expectation of having no faults whatsoever. Sadly, this type of "all-or-nothing" behavior can repeat over and over in one relationship after another until a person realizes that they themselves are the problem.

What can be done?
The best way to combat all-or-nothing behavior is to get in touch with unfulfilled expectations from past relationships. For those registered with eHarmony, the Top 10 Can't Stands and Must Haves are great tools to help refine real relationship needs so no one has to settle. For those dating and in relationships, enjoying current partners for who they are is important. Hammering someone to fit inside a set of unrealistic expectations that can never be met is a recipe for disaster, not to mention cruel and unusual punishment for the unsuspecting parties who are just being themselves.

Along these lines, another important step is to resist breaking up with an unsuspecting partner for temporary relief and the illusion of self-control because it only reinforces all-or-nothing behavior, and may hurt the other person. Truly accept and enjoy what they have to offer and teach you. One pleasurable side effect from accepting another is your own self-acceptance, and since lack of self-esteem is the basis of overly critical, all-or-nothing thinking, the more self-acceptance let in to your life, the happier you can be.

Love is not about all-or-nothing, it’s about the good, the bad and the everything. So starting right now, relax a little more; enjoy a little more, and shelve the judgments and criticisms that create your dissatisfaction. Once you start accepting others, you’ll accept yourself, and when you’re in touch with yourself, you’ll know exactly what you need to have the best relationship. And the best part? You may already be in that relationship.

Connect with people like you!
Rate this article:
starstarstarstarhalfstar
(Avg: 4.5 out of 5)
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Comments

24 comments on “What "All-or-Nothing" says about you


Leave a Comment

YOU WILL BE PROMPTED TO REGISTER OR LOG IN WHEN POSTING

Watch this topic

Recent comments on this article

Read all comments

Posts: 2168

See Profile

This sounds exactly like what I just went through with the last girl that I dated. We were together for about two months, and then all of a sudden she decided that she wanted to break up with me. When we first got together it was like 0 to 60 in the blink of an eye. At first I was afraid that it was too good to be true, but I just told myself to be happy and not worry about it not working out. In retrospect all of the warning signs in this article were there from beginning to end. We had a lot in common, and she was very attracted to me physically. Unfortunately, she never expressed to me what she desired as the relationship progressed. She assumed when we first got together that I was THE PERFECT PERSON for her, and that I should just be able to assume what she wanted without her telling me anything! We had just gotten out of school for the summer and were looking for jobs, so it wasn't like we could afford to go out to places a lot and do the really romantic things that I wanted to do for her (which was one reason she gave me for breaking up). I did everything that I could to be available to her when she was really feeling down on herself. I know very well what it is like to be insecure and get caught up in negative self talk and how important it is to have some one that you care about help pull you out of it. In retrospect, she did more complaining about herself than the majority of people I know, but I felt very strongly about her. Then all of a sudden, she began to turn on me after she returned from a trip back to her home town. We continued to be physically intimate, but some how I felt disconnected from her. I had invested so much emotional energy into her that I began to feel clingy and insecure when I hadn't before. It is my belief that she took this as a major sign of weakness and then took the initiative to break it off, just like that! She turned on me faster than I've ever seen. When we discussed why she wanted to break up, she said things like, "you never impressed me", "you never took me out", "there is something wrong with you" that she wouldn't care to articulate anymore than that. She said I "made her feel depressed", that I spent too much time in her house, that I never "criticized" her, that I never carried any cash on me, that she thought I wanted us to be like "an old married couple". I'm not saying I never did anything wrong. I know I did things that annoyed her. A fair amount of what she said was very reasonable to me, so I took what she said to heart. The next day she called me back and said she wanted to get back together! The day after that, I left the country for 10 days. While I was gone she repeatedly tried to get a hold of me until I could return her call, and left me messages on facebook. When I inquired whether or not she wanted to stay together she said that she hadn't changed her mind. When I got back, I had some extra money left from my trip, so I took her out to a nice bar, went to a movie with her, and then to dinner afterward. Later that week when she said she wanted to break up with me again, one of the reasons she gave is that I wanted to split an entre at the restaurant after I had already spent $60 dollars in one afternoon! Then it turned out that she met some one else at her work, and it was all over. It was a dream come true that turned into a nightmare. If I had only known what was in store for me, I would never have gone out with her in the first place.

Spencer...sorry to read your sad story. This is a woman with some serious emotionally issues. Hopefully you can spot this earlier next time. Good luck.

- June 08, 2008 08:44 PM

Posts: 4

See Profile

eharmony wrote:
This is my first time joining this site and I'm so impressed with the feedback. I read this article because I knew I had issues with all or nothing mentality but I had no idea to what extent. The article really helped me identify the troubles I was having with communication and over all perception of reality. Thank you for giving me more clarity after the 17 month break up. Sometimes I find myself in a undecided state about what I'm suppose to do. Should I completely forget the past and pretend it didn't really matter? or Should I try to spend enought time thinking about it to learn something. Well, I've decided to think about it. I find my self remembering old times, becoming sentimental and other times resolved. It's a hard process to break up after being engaged but it's possible to heal and move on. I see myself becoming stronger every day.
I feel the same. I broke up a 2-1/2 year relationship about 2 months ago. He continues to call me (occasionaly) and I can not seem to tell him to stop calling. (He now says that he loves me and doesn't understand that now that he's made this "breakthrough" I don't want to work on the relationship.) I broke up with him several times during those years and once he broke it off. You know writing this out is helping me. He would talk me into getting back together and trying again. I kept telling myself that "this thing he did or said" I was just going to ignore because there are other things I like about him. So I'd go along with things and then - boom - I'm upset and angry and breaking up with him. Over and over again and again. But this going back and forth in my mind with it is driving me crazy. Lack of self-esteem on my part could be part of the problem, but I think with me it is because I was widowed 7 years ago. Met someone and married again two years later. That marriage was a disaster. I do not want to do that again. So, do I have stuff to work on? Oh, yeah! Thanks for everyone writing. It's good not to feel alone here.
- May 15, 2008 10:00 AM

Posts: 2

See Profile

This is my first time joining this site and I'm so impressed with the feedback. I read this article because I knew I had issues with all or nothing mentality but I had no idea to what extent. The article really helped me identify the troubles I was having with communication and over all perception of reality. Thank you for giving me more clarity after the 17 month break up. Sometimes I find myself in a undecided state about what I'm suppose to do. Should I completely forget the past and pretend it didn't really matter? or Should I try to spend enought time thinking about it to learn something. Well, I've decided to think about it. I find my self remembering old times, becoming sentimental and other times resolved. It's a hard process to break up after being engaged but it's possible to heal and move on. I see myself becoming stronger every day.
- May 14, 2008 02:07 PM

24 comments so far » read more