Can Men and Women Just Be Friends?
Dear Dr. Warren,
As I date and search for a relationship partner I’m confronted with a recurring problem-- opposite sex friendships. What is your belief about opposite sex friendship when a person is married or dating someone?
Dr. Neil Clark Warren, Clinical Psychologist and eHarmony Founder
Dear Dr. Warren,
As I date and search for a relationship partner I’m confronted with a recurring problem, opposite sex friendships. Before I move forward with anyone I need to clearly establish how I feel on this matter.
What is your belief about opposite sex friendship when a person is married or dating someone?
-Kelly, KS
Kelly,
I have always been an enthusiastic proponent of deep rooted friendships with a variety of people. I believe that in most of our lives there will be one or two (or maybe more) episodes where your good and loving friends will, almost literally, save your life. The unconditional support these close friends provide will carry you though you darkest hours, when the rest of the world has seemingly turned against you. So, at the beginning I wanted to establish my complete support for the general concept of friendship, regardless of the gender of the friends.
The question you ask Kelly is really about the sort of friendship in question and the feelings of your spouse or boyfriend.
130 comments on
“Can Men and Women Just Be Friends?”
Yep. It's easier if there's also a certain power dynamic, but I have plenty of male friends. Of course I'm in my thirties, and those friends are as well or older. And we're not each other's types (or they're married/LTR meaning if they wanted "more" it would make them***holes.) If anything as a rule I tend to get on better with men, as I"m a bit pushy with women (I don't do the passive/emotive girly thing well and get very frustrated with women who do.) So it's easier to be friends with a man as I don't feel I have to be the alpha in the situation all the time. (Also men understand things like watching Top Gear or ripping apart competitors or your not-favorite athletes. Women are better for talking books and TV plots and stuff.)
- March 03, 2010 07:49 AM
[QUOTE=DoctorLove;279604]Absolutely. Part of this confusion stems from the media (books, films, television). [i]"When Harry Met Sally", "Friends" [/i]& [i]"Cheers" [/i]gave us cultural images that are difficult to overcome. It's little wonder why we expect that men and women are always on the road to romance when almost every time you see a male-female friendship, it eventually turns into romance.
There was a study done by a Don O'Meara, Ph.D., at the University of Cincinnatti-Raymond Walters College a few years ago. He started his own research because one of his best friends is a woman. He put it down in his journal called [i]Sex Roles. [/i]Here is what he found out:
Platonic love DOES exist. A study of 20 pairs of friends was published published in the [i]Journal of Social and Personal Relationships. [/i]In it, a woman confirmed that "friendship attraction" or a connection completely devoid of lust, is a bona fide type of bond that people experience. However, distinguishing between romantic, sexual, and friendly feelings can be very difficult.
In the same study, more than 150 professional men and women what they liked and disliked about their cross-sex friendships. Topping women's list of dislikes: sexual tension. Men, on the other hand, more often replied that sexual attraction was a prime reason for initiating a friendship, and that it could even deepen a friendship. Either way, 62 percent of all subjects reported that sexual tension was present in their cross-sex friendships.
Friendship should be a pairing of equals. But, O'Meara said, "in a culture where men have always been more equal than women, male dominance, prestige and power is baggage that both men and women are likely to bring to a relationship." Women are at risk of subconsciously adopting a more submissive role in cross-sex friendships, he said, although that is slowly changing as society begins to treat both genders more equally.
Some people believe that society may not be entirely ready for friendships between men and women that have no sexual subtext. People with close friends of the opposite sex are often barraged with nudging, winking and skepticism: "Are you really just friends?" O'Meara said that this is especially true of older adults who grew up when men and women were off-limits to each other until marriage.
As the workplace and other social arenas become increasingly open to women, the sexes are mingling more and more. Still, men and women continue to have surprisingly few opportunities to interact.
These obstacles may seem numerous and formidable, but male-female friendship is becoming not only a possibility but also a necessity. If men and women are to work, play and coexist in modern society, IMHO men and women must learn to understand and communicate with each other. The field of research is still in its infancy, but I think that people are now beginning to understand some basic truths about male-female friendship.[/QUOTE]
This study is suspect.
The barriers to pure friendship between men and women are not societal; they are biological. Men are simply not made to be just friends with women. The man always wants more but us afraid of rejection.
- March 02, 2010 04:23 PM
[QUOTE=J_Aeon;279564]yes men and women can be JUST friends there's gonna be a few times that you have friends that are just friends and not going anywhere else.[/QUOTE]
but the man always wants more
- March 02, 2010 04:19 PM
Not an Advice member? Sign up to contribute to the discussion.
Create an account above to save and post your reply. This information is private: only your screen name will be visible to other Advice members.
Advice members, log in to post your reply.
eHarmony account holders: your signup information will not work in the Advice Community. You must create an Advice screen name by using the sign-up form to the right.
Recent comments on this article
Read all comments